Sat Jul 16, 2005 08:03 EST (UTC -5)
To the delight of zillions of fans, "Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince" hit the shelves (only to fly off in an instant) at midnight. Even though nobody got it for me for my birthday, and I don't intend to buy it right away, my sister, her friend Katherine, and I thought we would celebrate the occasion yesterday with a quasi-magical recipe.
As several books in the obviously immensely popular series have attested, "butterbeer" appears to be the preferred beverage of Potter & Company. For a long time, knowledge of anything about this exotic-sounding drink had evaded me. Does it taste like butter? Does it taste like beer? Perhaps both? Is it even real?
On Thursday my eye caught a butterbeer recipe -- among other Harry-Potter-related ones -- in the newspaper, and so I just had to try it. So yesterday we Potter fans (or whatever they call themselves) got together for some sort of Potter Party, complete with authentic drinks.
(The units of measure used in this recipe are those archaic English measurements that we still use in America. I would convert them to metric for you, but I don't want to be held accountable if somebody's butterbeer exploded due to too much or too little of this or that.)
Ingredients:
1/2 stick (4 tablespoons) butter, at room temperature about 2 hours
1/3 cup light brown sugar
2 teaspoons ground cinnamon
1/2 teaspoon ground nutmeg
1/4 teaspoon ground cloves
1 pint vanilla ice cream, softened 30 minutes
1 (24-ounce) bottle (3 cups) sparkling apple cider

In a large bowl...

...cream together butter, sugar and spices. Add to ice cream...


...and refreeze. This took about an hour and a half, so we entertained ourselves in the meanwhile:

Pour out the appropriate amount of cider...

...and heat it in a pot over medium heat until warm but still carbonated (at least 3 minutes).

Fill each glass with a generous scoop of ice cream mixture. Pour warmed cider over ice cream; it will foam like beer, hence the name.

Got butterbeer?

Basically it tastes like what you think it tastes like: apple cider, vanilla ice cream, cinnamon, and nutmeg. Despite the name, it doesn't taste like butter. I don't know what beer tastes like.
It's an interesting blend of tastes hot and cold. Katherine thought hers was too hot, and my sister's thought hers was too cold. Mine tasted just right and I drank it up promptly. The recipe says it makes six servings, but we were basically able to split the batch up between us three.
You kind of have to like the sparkling apple cider in order to like this recipe. Otherwise it'll taste funky. It tasted kind of funky to me, but I could see why you'd go for it on a snowy day in Hogsmeade.
Now the ubiquitous cheesy smile shot:

See also these unrelated but cool pages with recipes for root beer and ginger ale.














. PGP key ID:
11 comments
#1 by Daniel | Sat Jul 16, 2005 20:30 EST (UTC -5)
Wow! So far the book is great! I'm on page 300, be sure and get it soon!
#2 by Jordon | Sat Jul 16, 2005 20:50 EST (UTC -5)
Actually, my dad bought the book for my sister and me today. Currently my sister is plowing through it (she's on page 211 as I type this), so she'll probably be finished before I have the chance to pick it up, which should be... Monday at the latest.
#3 by Eric Moritz | Sun Jul 17, 2005 20:13 EST (UTC -5)
That made me think of the Tibetan Butter Tea, basically Chai Tea with Butter instead of Milk.
#4 by Rena from Wheresgeorge | Mon Jul 18, 2005 01:39 EST (UTC -5)
I might just have to try that recipe.... sometime or other. Can't right now while trying to stick to my diet. ;)
I just finished Harry and the HBP a little bit ago. *sigh* Have you finished it?
#5 by Jordon | Mon Jul 18, 2005 08:01 EST (UTC -5)
My guess was right. My sister finished it yesterday (Sunday), so I'll start reading it today.
#6 by Tim | Tue Feb 27, 2007 01:51 EST (UTC -5)
Cider is alcoholic. If I were to exclude it, would the taste be any different? If it is different, then are there anything non-alcoholic that tastes similar to cider?
#7 by Jordon | Tue Feb 27, 2007 05:51 EST (UTC -5)
I think that without the cider, it would be undrinkable because it would just be ice cream. We used sparkling cider that was non-alcoholic. From the photos, the brand is apparently called Martinelli's. This seems to be it.
#8 by James | Mon Jun 18, 2007 16:01 EST (UTC -5)
Hey guys, thanks for the page! Getting ready to throw a huge party next month in celebration of the new movie and book release - whole spread (Chocolate Frogs, Jelly Slugs, etc.) and now I'll be serving Butterbeer as well! Cheers from Texas!!!! :)
#9 by Laura | Sun Jul 15, 2007 13:38 EST (UTC -5)
Easy Peasy Butter Beer : )
8 oz Rootbeer
3 tablespoons of butterscotch syrup
Mix in a glass and serve cold over ice.
Pumpkin Juice
Ingredients:
2 cups of pumpkin, chopped up into chunks
2 cups of apple juice
1/2 cup of pineapple juice
1 teaspoon of honey (to taste)
Cinnamon, Ginger, Nutmeg and/or Allspice (all ground, to taste)
Directions:
Juice the pumpkin pieces by squeezing through a cheesecloth or by using a juicer. Pour the pumpkin juice, apple juice and pineapple juice into a blender. Add the honey and spices, adjusting quantity to taste. Chill or serve over ice.
#10 by gRis | Thu Aug 02, 2007 17:26 EST (UTC -5)
hello i love this recipe im about to buy the ingredients so i can taste it yeah!!
thanks a lot for sharing it
#11 by Ice T | Tue Oct 09, 2007 09:37 EST (UTC -5)
man you dumbnut brtis and your weirdo mixes lol